Jimmy Eat World Site

I really like Jimmy Eat World, and I want to buy a CD, but for the time being, I only want to buy one.
I know two songs off Bleed American, and three off Chase This Light.
In your opinion, which one’s better? I can’t decide which to get. :p
After seeing how much all you guys liked Futures, I listened to some of those songs on myspace, and I actually like that one better than the other two I was looking at. I’m probably going to go with Futures now, thanks for suggesting it! :]